If your child has come home this term saying they “did English on the iPad”, you’re not imagining it. Screens have crept into a lot of classrooms, and this week the question of how much is too much became a full-blown political row.
On Sunday the Conservatives announced a plan to “slash screen use in schools and put pen and paper back at the heart of classrooms”. By Tuesday night the Telegraph was reporting that some schools have swapped textbooks for laptops and iPads to save money on printing. So, as a maths teacher who spends his days on both a whiteboard and a laptop, here’s my attempt at a calm look at what’s actually on the table.
What’s been proposed
The Conservative plan, set out by Kemi Badenoch and shadow education secretary Laura Trott, says that if the party returns to government it would:
- keep screens out of early years teaching altogether
- require primary schools to keep screen use to a minimum, using it only where the curriculum needs it, such as computing
- limit secondary pupils to a maximum of two hours of screen time a day, including homework
- stop the move towards on-screen exams and reduce coursework, partly because of worries about pupils leaning on AI tools like ChatGPT
- create a £250 million fund for physical textbooks, with an ambition of three new textbooks per pupil
Trott put it like this: “I want to slash screen use in classrooms and set a new norm where screens are no longer the default.”
It’s worth being clear that this is an opposition pledge, not a rule your child’s school has to follow.
What the government says
The Department for Education told the BBC that schools decide how much to spend on technology from their own budgets, and “it is up to schools to decide how they use their funding in the best interests of pupils.”
More usefully for parents, the department also said that “in the new year the department will publish clear guidance on screen use for all children aged 5 to 18”. That builds on the under fives guidance that came out earlier this autumn.
On exams, the BBC points out that the vast majority of school exams in the UK are still sat with pen and paper, and that Ofqual has said pen and paper will “remain central” for the most widely taken subjects for the foreseeable future.
Why doctors are involved
The row didn’t come from nowhere. Last month more than 150 clinicians, including GPs, paediatricians and eye specialists, wrote to Education Secretary Lucy Powell and Health Secretary Yvette Cooper. They said they were prescribing glasses, hearing aids and speech therapy to children “for a problem that is unintentionally being made worse in our schools”.
Dr Becky Foljambe, founder of Health Professionals for Safer Screens, told the BBC that “daily screen time can profoundly affect a child’s health, whatever they are watching or doing.”
How much are pupils actually on screens?
This is the bit that often gets lost. The most recent government survey, quoted by the BBC, found that in 2024 most teachers (89%) used an interactive whiteboard in lessons. But 79% of primary teachers and 69% of secondary teachers said pupils were using their own devices in fewer than a quarter of lessons, or not at all.
So for plenty of children, the “screen” at school is mostly the board at the front. For others, especially in schools that have gone all in on one device per pupil, it’s a much bigger part of the day. It really does vary from school to school.
My take from the staffroom
Honestly? Both things can be true. A laptop is brilliant for some jobs. Coding, research, a kid with dyslexia using text to speech, a quick quiz that tells me in seconds who’s got it and who hasn’t. But I also see what happens when a pupil writes something out by hand and has to think about it before the pen hits the paper. Working out a maths problem on paper, crossing things out, showing the steps, that’s where a lot of the learning happens.
What I’d be wary of is the debate turning into “screens bad, paper good” and nothing else. The useful question is what the screen is doing in that lesson, and whether a book and a pencil would do it better.
What dads can actually do
Ask, don’t assume. At the next parents’ evening, ask how much of your child’s day is spent on a personal device, and in which subjects. You’ll get a far clearer picture than from the school’s website.
Ask about homework. If homework is set online, ask whether there’s a paper option, and how long it’s expected to take. That matters if you’re also trying to keep a lid on screen time at home.
Keep some pen and paper at home. Handwritten shopping lists, letters to grandparents, a notebook for drawing. It sounds small, but it keeps the habit going, especially for younger ones still learning to form letters.
Watch for the physical signs. The clinicians’ letter talked about eyesight and speech. If your child is squinting, rubbing their eyes or getting headaches, book a free NHS eye test at an optician. Children under 16 are entitled to them.
Look out for the new guidance. When the DfE publishes its 5 to 18 screen guidance in the new year, it’ll be worth a read, and a good prompt for a chat with your school.
The pen versus tablet debate will rumble on well past Christmas. In the meantime, the most powerful thing you can do is find out what actually happens in your child’s classroom, and back the bits that help them learn.
Join Dadsnet
Weekly dad stuff that actually helps. No spam, just the good bits.







